Workers’ compensation insurance is essential for businesses, ensuring that employees are protected in case of work-related injuries or illnesses. Underwriting this type of insurance, however, is a complex process, as it requires a thorough evaluation of various risks. For underwriters, the goal is to balance fair premium rates with adequate coverage, while minimizing the risk to the insurer. Let’s walk through the key steps of workers’ compensation underwriting and explore the challenges that arise at each stage.

Key Steps in Workers’ Compensation Underwriting

Gathering Essential Information

The first step in the workers’ compensation underwriting process involves collecting detailed information about the business seeking coverage. Underwriters need to know:

• The type of business or industry
• The number of employees and their roles
• Safety protocols in place
• Check the relevant OSHA website
• Search for the business information on the relevant SOS site

Each of these factors plays a crucial role in assessing the risk level. For example, a construction company will naturally present a higher risk than an office-based business.

2. Classifying Employees

One of the unique aspects of workers’ compensation underwriting is the classification of employees based on their job functions. Workers are categorized using industry-specific classification codes that reflect their level of risk. Underwriters need to ensure that employees are classified correctly, as misclassification can lead to inaccurate premiums or insufficient coverage.

For instance, an employee who splits their time between office work and fieldwork should be classified under the riskier of the two functions.

3. Evaluating Loss History

The loss history of a business is a key indicator of its risk profile. Underwriters review past claims to identify patterns in workplace accidents and assess whether the business has effective safety protocols in place. High claim frequency or severity may indicate a risky environment and result in higher premiums or even denial of coverage.

Additionally, underwriters consider the company’s Experience Modification Rate (EMR). A high EMR indicates that a company has had more claims than others in the same industry, leading to increased premiums.

4. Assessing Risk Factors

This step involves a deeper dive into the company’s specific risk exposures. Underwriters look at factors such as:

• The physical environment of the workplace
• The type of machinery and equipment used
• Ergonomics and how well the company manages repetitive strain risks
• Training programs and safety measures
• Look at the business’s website for information that could suggest additional exposure (ex: the location of the business, if the business has a pool or live music, etc.)
• Reference social sites that can provide the social sentiment about the business (ex: Glassdoor, TripAdvisor, the business own social media accounts).

This analysis helps the underwriter determine if the business has a proactive approach to preventing accidents or if there are gaps that increase the likelihood of claims.

Download the workers’ Comp Underwriting Checklist

5. Determining the Premium

After gathering and analyzing all relevant information, underwriters calculate the premium. This is based on:

• The company’s payroll (since premiums are often calculated per $100 of payroll)
• Employee classifications
• Risk factors identified in the business operations
• Loss history and EMR

Adjustments may be made based on factors like the business’s commitment to improving safety measures, industry trends, or new risk management tools implemented by the company.

Common Challenges in Workers’ Compensation Underwriting

While the process may seem straightforward, several challenges complicate workers’ compensation underwriting:

1. Employee Misclassification

One of the most significant challenges in workers’ compensation underwriting is the correct classification of employees. If workers are misclassified—either intentionally or unintentionally—it can lead to significant discrepancies in premiums and coverage. Overclassification can result in inflated premiums, while under classification can leave businesses underinsured and exposed to greater risk.

2. Inconsistent or Incomplete Data

Underwriters rely on accurate and complete data to assess risk, but sometimes businesses fail to provide comprehensive information. Missing or inconsistent data can lead to inaccurate risk assessments and potentially wrong pricing. It also increases the likelihood of disputes or discrepancies during claims processing.

3. Industry-Specific Risks

Some industries, such as construction or manufacturing, have inherent risks that can be difficult to quantify. In industries with high-risk variability, accurately pricing workers’ compensation policies becomes more challenging. Factors like evolving regulations, seasonal variations in work activity, and exposure to hazardous materials add layers of complexity to the underwriting process.

4. Evolving Workforce Dynamics

The nature of work is changing, and many businesses now have a mix of full-time employees, part-time workers, and independent contractors. This shift makes it more difficult for underwriters to classify workers and assess risks accurately. In particular, determining which workers are eligible for coverage and which are not can be confusing for both the business and the underwriter.

5. Fraud and Claims Abuse

Fraudulent claims or claim abuse can pose significant challenges for workers’ compensation underwriters. When businesses or employees falsify claims, it inflates the insurer’s losses and can skew the company’s risk profile. Underwriters must be vigilant in identifying red flags for fraudulent activity, but detecting fraud is difficult and requires sophisticated tools and analytics.

Download the Complete Workers’ Compensation Underwriting Checklist

The Future of Workers’ Compensation Underwriting

As technology continues to evolve, the workers’ compensation underwriting process is becoming more efficient and accurate. Predictive analytics, artificial intelligence (AI), and risk modeling tools help underwriters identify emerging risks and price policies more accurately. Additionally, digital platforms enable faster access to data, streamlining the underwriting process.

However, despite these advancements, human judgment and expertise remain essential. No algorithm can fully replace the nuanced understanding that experienced underwriters bring to the table.

Conclusion

Workers’ compensation underwriting involves multiple steps and challenges, from gathering detailed information and classifying employees to accurately assessing risk and determining premiums. While it is a complex and ever-evolving process, modern technology and a proactive approach to risk management can help businesses and underwriters achieve the best outcomes.

At Mulberri, we specialize in creating technology-driven solutions that streamline the underwriting process, making it easier for businesses and insurers to navigate these complexities. Connect with us to learn more about how we’re transforming the way workers’ compensation insurance is underwritten.

Download the Full Underwriters’ Checklist